Your 'Right `To Work' checks might be costing you more than you think

TL;DR

Even well-meaning employers can make costly mistakes with right to work checks. Errors can lead to fines up to £60,000, reputational damage, and wasted time. A proactive HR consultant in South East London ensures your hiring processes are compliant

As an HR consultant in South East London, I help businesses understand why even well-intentioned employers can fall foul of right to work regulations. Compliance isn’t just paperwork it’s about safeguarding your profits, reputation, and peace of mind from Home Office penalties.

Your 'right to work' checks might be costing you more than you think: The common trap: why your 'proof' might not be enough

Misunderstanding acceptable documents

Many employers think a National Insurance number, P45, or benefits paperwork proves work eligibility. Unfortunately, these do not meet legal requirements. Only original documents from the Home Office’s approved list or a certified digital identity check legally satisfy the process.

Mistimed checks

All right to work checks must be completed before day one of employment. Waiting until the employee starts, or relying on partial documentation, can put your business at risk.

Incomplete records

Even if you check documents correctly, failing to retain copies with dates of inspection removes your legal protection. Proper documentation demonstrates due diligence if audited by the Home Office.

The non-negotiable rules for right to work checks

Inspect original documents

Physically inspect approved original documents or use an approved digital identity service before the employee starts working. This ensures compliance and avoids costly fines.

Take and keep copies

Record a clear copy of the documents and write the date of inspection directly on them. This is your proof of due diligence.

Complete checks before employment

All inspections and document copies must be done before the employee’s first day. Delays or partial compliance can invalidate your checks.

Retain records

Keep copies for the duration of employment plus two additional years after they leave. This protects your business in the event of Home Office inspection.

The consequences of getting it wrong

Hefty fines

Businesses can face fines of up to £60,000 per illegal worker. Repeat offences are particularly expensive.

No protection for unintentional mistakes

Even if your mistake is honest, the Home Office does not offer exceptions for ignorance.

Increased enforcement

The Home Office has intensified audits and enforcement, meaning the risk of non-compliance is higher than ever.

Reputational damage and stress

Beyond fines, non-compliance can damage relationships with clients, employees, and partners, while creating stress and distraction for business owners.

Practical steps to make your process watertight

Audit your current process

Review how checks are currently handled. Are all documents inspected? Are copies kept and dated? Are checks done before day one?

Train your team

Ensure anyone involved in hiring, from managers to HR staff, understands the legal requirements and follows consistent procedures.

Implement a documented system

Create a step-by-step, compliant system for every new hire. This reduces errors and provides peace of mind.

How an HR consultant can help you navigate this complexity

Reviewing your current processes

Identify gaps and potential risks in your existing right to work checks.

Creating compliant procedures

Develop clear, legally compliant processes tailored to your business.

Training your team

Provide hands-on guidance for managers and administrators so they fully understand their responsibilities.

Tools and templates

Supply practical checklists, templates, and documentation systems to make compliance straightforward.

Ongoing support

Offer continuous guidance to ensure your business grows safely, reducing legal and financial risks.

Protect your business and peace of mind

Getting right to work checks wrong isn’t just a compliance issue, it’s a business risk. By ensuring all checks are robust, documented, and completed correctly, you protect your profits, reputation, and peace of mind.

Ready to make your right to work checks watertight?

If you’re unsure whether your processes are robust, and are worried your 'right to work' checks might be costing you more than you think, let’s talk. As an outsourced HR consultant in South East London, I help businesses make right to work compliance simple and stress-free.

Book a confidential call today and discover how you can protect your business, save time, and focus on growth with confidence.

Lets Chat